Skip to main content
US EQUITIES CLOSED CRYPTO 24/7
HALAL TRADING ROOM Sharia-screened signals
Screen a stock
TERMINAL

This article compares the screeners Muslim investors most often ask about — Zoya, Musaffa, Islamicly, Halal Terminal, HalalScreener and IdealRatings — and the Shariah index families that institutional money follows. It does not rank them. A ranking would need a fair test of whose verdicts are correct, and no such test exists: the screeners apply different, legitimately held standards. What can be compared is how much each one lets you check. Every figure below is taken from the provider's own published pages as we read them in November 2026, and where a provider does not state something, we say so rather than guess.

On this page 7 sections

1. What makes a screener reliable

Freshness. A verdict is only as current as the filing it was computed from. Companies report every quarter, and a balance sheet can change a lot in three months — a bond issue, a large acquisition, a cash pile that grows. A screener that works from the last annual report can be nine months or more behind the company. Look for the date of the figures, not the date the page was refreshed: those are different things, and a page that was rebuilt today from a year-old filing is still a year old.

Transparency. The answer should come with its working: the debt ratio, the cash and interest-bearing securities ratio, the share of income that is impermissible, the threshold each was tested against, and the period each figure describes. Without those, a verdict cannot be checked against the company's own report, and a borderline pass looks exactly like a comfortable one.

Shariah oversight. A named board or scholar who approves the methodology gives the rules a religious authority that software alone cannot. It is worth knowing what the oversight covers, though: in most consumer apps the scholars approve the method, and the individual verdicts are produced by applying it to data automatically.

Coverage. A screener that covers only US stocks is no help with a London or Kuala Lumpur listing, and one that covers the whole world may rest some of its markets on annual reports only. Coverage figures in marketing copy are also hard to compare: some count every listing, some count companies, and some include funds.

A named standard. “Halal” is not one rule. A screener should say which published standard it applies — AAOIFI, Dow Jones Islamic, S&P, MSCI, FTSE — or, if it uses its own, publish the formula.

2. Why two screeners can disagree

The most common reason is not an error on either side. The published standards draw their lines in different places and against different denominators. AAOIFI tests interest-bearing debt at 30% of current market capitalisation. The Dow Jones Islamic Market indices use 33% of a 24-month average market capitalisation, and the S&P Shariah indices 33% of a 36-month average. MSCI and FTSE measure against total assets at 33.33%. A company whose debt sits at 31% of today’s market value fails AAOIFI and can pass the other four on the same figures; a share-price fall can move it across the AAOIFI line without the company borrowing anything.

The second reason is timing: two screeners that read different quarters of the same company can reach different answers, and both are describing a real filing. The third is classification. Whether a revenue line counts as impermissible — an advertising business, a customer-financing arm, a defence contract — is a judgement, and screeners make it differently. Our methodology disagreement page lists real companies where the published standards split.

3. The screeners, side by side

What each provider states about itself on its own pages, read in November 2026. Prices and coverage claims change; check the provider before relying on any of them.

ScreenerStandard it appliesShariah oversight it namesCoverage it claimsUpdate cadence it states
ZoyaInvestroo Inc.AAOIFI by default: debt and interest-bearing assets each under 30% of market cap, impermissible revenue under 5%Sheikh Joe Bradford and Sheikh Umer Khan, named as Shariah advisors“Over 60,000 stocks globally” in one place and “over 40,000 stocks, ETFs and mutual funds” in another; funds US-onlyFollows each company’s reporting: US at least quarterly, non-US semi-annually or annually
MusaffaAAOIFI-based: 5% impermissible income; interest-bearing assets and debt each under 30%, its published formula dividing by a trailing 36-month average market valueCertified by Amanah Advisors; names Shaikh Dr. Aznan Hasan and Mufti Faraz Adam“120,000+ stocks and 8,200+ ETFs across 60 markets”Not stated on its methodology page
IslamiclyOwn published criteria on a 36-month average market value: debt under 30%, receivables under 49%, impermissible income under 5%; the cash test is given as 30% in one place and 33% in anotherA Shariah board chaired by Dr. Mohamed A. Elgari, with Dr. Mohammad Amin Ali Qattan and Dr. Nazih HammadListed markets across six regions; no company count statedDaily, using the latest statement whether quarterly, semi-annual or annual
Halal TerminalFive published standards side by side: AAOIFI, Dow Jones Islamic, FTSE, MSCI and S&PNone named“200,000+ global assets” across “25+ exchanges”Not stated for screening data
HalalScreenerAAOIFI Standard 21 as written: 30% / 30% of market cap, 5% impermissible incomeNone; states “we screen, we do not certify”“7,100+” US stocks, ETFs and crypto in one place and “8,200+” in another, plus some ADRs and Bursa MalaysiaRe-screens within 48 hours of an earnings release
IdealRatingsfor institutionsFor the FTSE Russell IdealRatings indices: debt and cash each under 30% of a 12-month average market cap, cash plus receivables under 67% of total assets, 5% impermissible incomeIndex mandate approved by Dr Mohamed Elgari, Dr M. Daud Bakar and Sheikh Yusuf Talal DeLorenzoNot stated in the index factsheetIndex constituents screened quarterly

4. What each one is good at, and where to be careful

Zoya is a consumer app for checking individual stocks and funds, with a free tier and a paid subscription. Its strength is a clearly stated default standard (AAOIFI), named advisors, and an explicit statement that compliance reports follow each company’s own reporting schedule. Its methodology article, dated 14 April 2026, gives the AAOIFI thresholds but does not say whether market capitalisation is taken on the day or averaged, and the coverage figures on its own homepage do not agree with each other.

Musaffa publishes its three ratio formulas and names its scholars and certifying firm, which is more than most. Two things are worth knowing. It applies AAOIFI’s 30% line to a 36-month average market value — a combination that sits between AAOIFI, which uses current market cap, and the index providers, who use 33% — so a company near 30% can fail Musaffa while passing the indices. And its methodology page does not say how often the underlying figures are refreshed.

Islamicly has the most clearly described Shariah board of the consumer apps, states that it screens daily on the latest available statement, and publishes a receivables test that several others omit. Its own page is internally inconsistent on the cash threshold (30% in one passage, 33% in another), so check which applies to the stock you are looking at.

Halal Terminal is a web terminal and a paid developer API rather than a phone app. Its distinguishing feature is that it reports five published standards side by side instead of one verdict, which is the most honest way to show a borderline company. It names no Shariah board and does not state how often its screening data is refreshed; its published prices run from a free tier to $49 a month for the terminal’s Pro plan, with API plans priced by monthly token allowance.

HalalScreener applies AAOIFI Standard 21 without modification and says it re-screens a company within 48 hours of its earnings release, which is a concrete freshness promise. It names its data vendor, names no scholar, and is explicit that it screens rather than certifies. Its Pro plan is listed at $9.99 a month.

IdealRatings is not a consumer app. It is a screening firm that supplies institutions and the FTSE Russell IdealRatings index family; its index factsheet describes quarterly screening under an AAOIFI-based mandate approved by three named scholars. If an Islamic fund you hold uses IdealRatings data, that factsheet is where its rules come from.

5. The institutional reference: Shariah index families

Most Islamic equity funds and ETFs do not use a consumer app. They track an index whose provider publishes a full methodology document and appoints a Shariah board. The Dow Jones Islamic Market indices (S&P Dow Jones Indices) limit interest-bearing debt to 33% of a trailing 24-month average market capitalisation, a rule restated in S&P DJI’s August 2026 index announcement; the S&P Shariah indices use a 36-month average. The MSCI Islamic indices measure debt and cash against total assets at 33.33%, apply a lower 30% to new inclusions, re-test constituents at each quarterly index review, and are reviewed by an independent Sharia board that granted a fatwa on the methodology in 2007. FTSE runs its own Shariah series on total assets, with a looser 50% limit on cash plus receivables.

These are the most heavily scrutinised rule sets in the field, which makes them a good reference point. Their limitation for an individual investor is that an index answers “is this company in the index”, which depends on the index’s universe and review calendar, not “is this company compliant today”. MSCI published a consultation in 2024 on changing some of its thresholds; we have not been able to confirm from MSCI’s current methodology whether those changes took effect, so the figures above are the ones in its published methodology.

6. How Halal Trading Room screens

Since this site is in the same business, it should be held to the same five tests. It computes its own ratios from the figures each company files and publishes the result under seven standards side by side — AAOIFI, Usmani, Dow Jones Islamic, S&P Shariah, MSCI Islamic, MSCI Islamic M-Series and FTSE — rather than one blended answer, so a stock that passes some and fails others is shown as exactly that. Each symbol page shows the filed figure behind each ratio, the threshold it was tested against, and the period-end date of the filing. A company whose latest filing is more than about eighteen months old gets no verdict at all. The purification calculator shows the impermissible-income division from the company’s own filing.

Two limits, stated plainly. This site has no Shariah board; it offers the published standards and the arithmetic instead, and says so on the About page. And the date on a verdict is the date of the filing it was computed from, which is not always the newest one: when we checked thirty large US-listed technology companies for the companion article Are AI Stocks Halal? on 15 November 2026, eighteen had a newer quarterly or annual report on file with the SEC than the one their verdict here was based on. The date is printed so that you can see that, and the same test is worth applying to any screener you use.

A practical routine

Pick the standard you, or a scholar you trust, follow, and use a screener that applies it by name. For any stock you are about to buy, check the date of the figures against the company’s latest quarterly report. If the verdict is close to a line, or two screeners disagree, open both and compare the ratios rather than the labels — the disagreement usually comes from the standard or the filing date, and knowing which tells you what to do. Then remember that screening decides what you may own, not what you may keep: see Dividend Purification.

This is a research article, not a fatwa, and none of it is financial advice. Screening reflects a methodology, and no screener — this one included — replaces your own due diligence or a qualified scholar’s guidance on your circumstances. When in doubt, consult a qualified scholar.

Terms used here are defined in the Islamic finance glossary, and every threshold this site applies is on the methodology page. For the instrument questions that sit beside stock screening, see Is Stock Trading Halal? and Are ETFs and Index Funds Halal?.

See also: All articles · Methodology · Where standards disagree · Are AI Stocks Halal? · Full Compliance List · Not financial or religious advice.