MOTIETF / FundVanEck Morningstar International Moat ETF
Verdicts genuinely change. Free email alert the moment MOTI's does — no target price to set, unlike a price alert.
Whether this fund clears the published standards, and the filings behind that answer. The screen runs first and nothing on the trading side can override it.
Structure, momentum, positioning and levels. Separate from the Sharia verdict above, which this side never overrides.
VanEck Morningstar International Moat ETF ETF · VanEck ETF Trust
47 holdings · as of 2026-06-30 (4.3 months ago) The fund may have traded since. SEC Form N-PORT is filed quarterly and lags the period it covers, so these are the most recent holdings on file, not the fund’s holdings today.
This fund holds short positions, so exposure is counted gross — long and short both count as exposure rather than netting off, and the weights below therefore sum to 101% of net assets rather than 100%. Shares of the portfolio are shown as shares of that gross exposure.
NON-COMPLIANT 38.31% of portfolio weight is in non-compliant holdings, over the 5% threshold.
47 holdings, 40 matched (87% of weight). Portfolio as of 2026-06-30, filed 2026-08-26. Source: SEC Form N-PORT.
2.04% of this portfolio’s income is non-permissible — weighted across holdings, computed over 84% of portfolio weight (39 of 47 holdings). The common approach purifies that proportion of income received — dividends — not of the position’s value. We report the ratio; what to do with it is a question for your own scholar.
48.8% compliant 0.0% questionable 37.8% non-compliant 13.4% unscreened
All holdings (47)
| Holding | Status | Weight | Every methodology, and the debt ratio behind it |
|---|---|---|---|
| DSFIR.AS DSM-Firmenich AG | COMPLIANT | 3.62% | AAOIFIpass Usmanipass Dow Jones Islamicpass S&P Shariahpass MSCI Islamicpass MSCI Islamic M-Seriespass FTSE Shariahpass |
| SY1.DE Symrise AG | COMPLIANT | 3.16% | AAOIFIpass Usmanifail Dow Jones Islamicpass S&P Shariahpass MSCI Islamicpass MSCI Islamic M-Seriespass FTSE Shariahpass |
| EDEN.PA Edenred SE | NON_COMPLIANT | 2.94% | AAOIFIfail Usmanifail Dow Jones Islamicfail S&P Shariahfail MSCI Islamicfail MSCI Islamic M-Seriesfail FTSE Shariahfail |
| UMG.AS Universal Music Group NV | COMPLIANT | 2.72% | AAOIFI13.5% Usmani22.7% Dow Jones Islamicpass S&P Shariahpass MSCI Islamic19.5% MSCI Islamic M-Seriespass FTSE Shariah19.5% |
| 8113.T Unicharm Corp | COMPLIANT | 2.68% | AAOIFIpass Usmanipass Dow Jones Islamicpass S&P Shariahpass MSCI Islamicfail MSCI Islamic M-Seriespass FTSE Shariahpass |
| PHG Koninklijke Philips NV | NON_COMPLIANT | 2.66% | AAOIFI37.6% Usmani30.0% Dow Jones Islamic39.2% S&P Shariah42.2% MSCI Islamic30.0% MSCI Islamic M-Series42.2% FTSE Shariah30.0% |
| BVI.PA Bureau Veritas SA | COMPLIANT | 2.64% | AAOIFIpass Usmanifail Dow Jones Islamicpass S&P Shariahpass MSCI Islamicfail MSCI Islamic M-Seriespass FTSE Shariahfail |
| 3092.T ZOZO Inc | COMPLIANT | 2.62% | AAOIFIpass Usmanifail Dow Jones Islamicpass S&P Shariahpass MSCI Islamicfail MSCI Islamic M-Seriespass FTSE Shariahfail |
| SPX.L Spirax Group PLC | COMPLIANT | 2.62% | AAOIFIpass Usmanifail Dow Jones Islamicpass S&P Shariahpass MSCI Islamicfail MSCI Islamic M-Seriespass FTSE Shariahfail |
| MRO.L Melrose Industries PLC | COMPLIANT | 2.58% | AAOIFIpass Usmanipass Dow Jones Islamicpass S&P Shariahpass MSCI Islamicpass MSCI Islamic M-Seriespass FTSE Shariahpass |
| EDV.AX Endeavour Group Ltd/Australia | NON_COMPLIANT | 2.53% | AAOIFIfail Usmanifail Dow Jones Islamicfail S&P Shariahfail MSCI Islamicfail MSCI Islamic M-Seriesfail FTSE Shariahfail |
| 600887.SS Inner Mongolia Yili Industrial Group Co Ltd | COMPLIANT | 2.50% | AAOIFIpass Usmanifail Dow Jones Islamicpass S&P Shariahpass MSCI Islamicfail MSCI Islamic M-Seriespass FTSE Shariahfail |
| RI.PA Pernod Ricard SA | NON_COMPLIANT | 2.50% | AAOIFIfail Usmanifail Dow Jones Islamicfail S&P Shariahfail MSCI Islamicfail MSCI Islamic M-Seriesfail FTSE Shariahfail |
| Dassault Systemes SE | UNSCREENED | 2.47% | no in-house ratios for this holding |
| HO.PA Thales SA | NON_COMPLIANT | 2.46% | AAOIFIfail Usmanifail Dow Jones Islamicfail S&P Shariahfail MSCI Islamicfail MSCI Islamic M-Seriesfail FTSE Shariahfail |
| PRX.AS Prosus NV | NON_COMPLIANT | 2.46% | AAOIFIfail Usmanifail Dow Jones Islamicfail S&P Shariahfail MSCI Islamicfail MSCI Islamic M-Seriesfail FTSE Shariahfail |
| JD JD.com Inc | NON_COMPLIANT | 2.45% | AAOIFI28.5% Usmani11.2% Dow Jones Islamic12.5% S&P Shariah13.4% MSCI Islamic11.2% MSCI Islamic M-Series13.4% FTSE Shariah6.4% |
| SHL.DE Siemens Healthineers AG | COMPLIANT | 2.44% | AAOIFIpass Usmanipass Dow Jones Islamicpass S&P Shariahpass MSCI Islamicpass MSCI Islamic M-Seriespass FTSE Shariahpass |
| 0700.HK Tencent Holdings Ltd | COMPLIANT | 2.42% | AAOIFIpass Usmani— Dow Jones Islamic— S&P Shariah— MSCI Islamic— MSCI Islamic M-Series— FTSE Shariah— |
| ADYEN.AS Adyen NV | NON_COMPLIANT | 2.41% | AAOIFIfail Usmanifail Dow Jones Islamicfail S&P Shariahfail MSCI Islamicfail MSCI Islamic M-Seriesfail FTSE Shariahfail |
| RELX RELX PLC | COMPLIANT | 2.41% | AAOIFI16.2% Usmani49.2% Dow Jones Islamic12.5% S&P Shariah12.8% MSCI Islamic49.2% MSCI Islamic M-Series12.8% FTSE Shariah49.2% |
| SF Holding Co Ltd | UNSCREENED | 2.36% | no in-house ratios for this holding |
| HAG.DE Hensoldt AG | NON_COMPLIANT | 2.32% | AAOIFIfail Usmanifail Dow Jones Islamicfail S&P Shariahfail MSCI Islamicfail MSCI Islamic M-Seriesfail FTSE Shariahfail |
| YUMC Yum China Holdings Inc | NON_COMPLIANT | 2.30% | AAOIFI14.8% Usmani21.2% Dow Jones Islamic13.5% S&P Shariah14.0% MSCI Islamic20.7% MSCI Islamic M-Series14.0% FTSE Shariah0.6% |
| EKTA-B.ST Elekta AB | NON_COMPLIANT | 2.24% | AAOIFIfail Usmanipass Dow Jones Islamicfail S&P Shariahfail MSCI Islamicpass MSCI Islamic M-Seriesfail FTSE Shariahpass |
| Luzhou Laojiao Co Ltd | UNSCREENED | 2.24% | no in-house ratios for this holding |
| 002304.SZ Jiangsu Yanghe Distillery Co Ltd | NON_COMPLIANT | 2.23% | AAOIFIfail Usmanifail Dow Jones Islamicfail S&P Shariahfail MSCI Islamicfail MSCI Islamic M-Seriesfail FTSE Shariahfail |
| Wuliangye Yibin Co Ltd | UNSCREENED | 2.22% | no in-house ratios for this holding |
| SAP SAP SE | COMPLIANT | 2.17% | AAOIFI3.5% Usmani13.0% Dow Jones Islamic3.1% S&P Shariah3.4% MSCI Islamic10.6% MSCI Islamic M-Series3.4% FTSE Shariah10.6% |
| 7974.T Nintendo Co Ltd | COMPLIANT | 2.17% | AAOIFIpass Usmanifail Dow Jones Islamicpass S&P Shariahpass MSCI Islamicfail MSCI Islamic M-Seriespass FTSE Shariahfail |
| TSM Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co Ltd | COMPLIANT | 2.14% | AAOIFI1.5% Usmani13.8% Dow Jones Islamic0.5% S&P Shariah0.6% MSCI Islamic13.4% MSCI Islamic M-Series0.6% FTSE Shariah13.4% |
| BABA Alibaba Group Holding Ltd | COMPLIANT | 2.05% | AAOIFI7.6% Usmani1.1% Dow Jones Islamic0.2% S&P Shariah0.2% MSCI Islamic1.1% MSCI Islamic M-Series0.2% FTSE Shariah0.0% |
| WiseTech Global Ltd | UNSCREENED | 1.93% | no in-house ratios for this holding |
| RHM.DE Rheinmetall AG | NON_COMPLIANT | 1.89% | AAOIFIfail Usmanifail Dow Jones Islamicfail S&P Shariahfail MSCI Islamicfail MSCI Islamic M-Seriesfail FTSE Shariahfail |
| NOVO-B.CO Novo Nordisk A/S | COMPLIANT | 1.75% | AAOIFIpass Usmanipass Dow Jones Islamicpass S&P Shariahpass MSCI Islamicpass MSCI Islamic M-Seriespass FTSE Shariahpass |
| MTX.DE MTU Aero Engines AG | NON_COMPLIANT | 1.53% | AAOIFIfail Usmanifail Dow Jones Islamicfail S&P Shariahfail MSCI Islamicfail MSCI Islamic M-Seriesfail FTSE Shariahfail |
| DIM.PA Sartorius Stedim Biotech | COMPLIANT | 1.52% | AAOIFIpass Usmanifail Dow Jones Islamicpass S&P Shariahpass MSCI Islamicpass MSCI Islamic M-Seriespass FTSE Shariahpass |
| ABEV3.SA Ambev SA | NON_COMPLIANT | 1.49% | AAOIFIfail Usmanifail Dow Jones Islamicfail S&P Shariahfail MSCI Islamicfail MSCI Islamic M-Seriesfail FTSE Shariahfail |
| 4661.T Oriental Land Co Ltd/Japan | COMPLIANT | 1.41% | AAOIFIpass Usmanifail Dow Jones Islamicpass S&P Shariahpass MSCI Islamicfail MSCI Islamic M-Seriespass FTSE Shariahfail |
| ASX.AX ASX Ltd | NON_COMPLIANT | 1.40% | AAOIFI2.6% Usmani2.0% Dow Jones Islamicfail S&P Shariahfail MSCI Islamic1.8% MSCI Islamic M-Seriesfail FTSE Shariah1.8% |
| RKT.L Reckitt Benckiser Group PLC | COMPLIANT | 1.38% | AAOIFIpass Usmanifail Dow Jones Islamicpass S&P Shariahpass MSCI Islamicfail MSCI Islamic M-Seriespass FTSE Shariahfail |
| DGE.L Diageo PLC | NON_COMPLIANT | 1.29% | AAOIFIfail Usmanifail Dow Jones Islamicfail S&P Shariahfail MSCI Islamicfail MSCI Islamic M-Seriesfail FTSE Shariahfail |
| EXPN.L Experian PLC | COMPLIANT | 1.25% | AAOIFIpass Usmanifail Dow Jones Islamicpass S&P Shariahpass MSCI Islamicfail MSCI Islamic M-Seriespass FTSE Shariahfail |
| BA.L BAE Systems PLC | NON_COMPLIANT | 1.21% | AAOIFIfail Usmanifail Dow Jones Islamicfail S&P Shariahfail MSCI Islamicfail MSCI Islamic M-Seriesfail FTSE Shariahfail |
| Shanxi Xinghuacun Fen Wine Factory Co Ltd | UNSCREENED | 1.19% | no in-house ratios for this holding |
| State Street Global Advisors | UNSCREENED | 1.15% | no in-house ratios for this holding |
| COLO-B.CO Coloplast A/S | COMPLIANT | 1.13% | AAOIFIpass Usmanifail Dow Jones Islamicpass S&P Shariahpass MSCI Islamicfail MSCI Islamic M-Seriespass FTSE Shariahfail |
The published standards disagree about this fund by 22 points of portfolio weight — 49.6% of it passes S&P Shariah, 27.2% passes MSCI Islamic. Which number is yours depends on which standard you follow.
These bars are the financial-ratio result under each standard — debt, receivables and interest income. They do not screen what the business does, so a holding can pass every ratio here and still be questionable or non-compliant on activity. The blended verdict above accounts for both.
ratios pass on 49.6% ratios fail on 38.1% 13.6% not rated under AAOIFI
ratios pass on 27.6% ratios fail on 55.6% 18.0% not rated under Usmani
ratios pass on 47.2% ratios fail on 36.0% 18.0% not rated under Dow Jones Islamic
ratios pass on 49.6% ratios fail on 33.6% 18.0% not rated under S&P Shariah
ratios pass on 27.2% ratios fail on 56.0% 18.0% not rated under MSCI Islamic
ratios pass on 47.2% ratios fail on 36.0% 18.0% not rated under MSCI Islamic M-Series
ratios pass on 32.3% ratios fail on 50.9% 18.0% not rated under FTSE Shariah
40 of 47 listed holdings carry our own per-methodology verdicts (88% of weight). The rest hold a provider verdict with no methodology breakdown, and are counted as rated by none. Of those, 9 (20% of weight) also carry the underlying debt ratio; the rest show a verdict without the figure behind it.
| Non-compliant holding | Weight |
|---|---|
| EDEN.PA Edenred SE | 2.94% |
| PHG Koninklijke Philips NV | 2.66% |
| EDV.AX Endeavour Group Ltd/Australia | 2.53% |
| RI.PA Pernod Ricard SA | 2.50% |
| HO.PA Thales SA | 2.46% |
| PRX.AS Prosus NV | 2.46% |
| JD JD.com Inc | 2.45% |
| ADYEN.AS Adyen NV | 2.41% |
| HAG.DE Hensoldt AG | 2.32% |
| YUMC Yum China Holdings Inc | 2.30% |
Methodology breakdown computing — it will appear here on its own.
Trade setup
Whether the technical picture shows an edge right now. Separate from the Sharia verdict, which this side never overrides.
Why this signal?
The factors behind the read, each shown with the figure it rests on, including the ones pointing the other way.
VanEck Morningstar International Moat ETF (MOTI) is currently considered not halal (non-compliant), per our own look-through to its filed holdings. See its filed holdings and the weight breakdown below for the reasoning.
🕌 In-house Compliance Research
Computing the full ratio and business-activity breakdown for MOTI — this runs off the critical path so the page paints first. It will appear here on its own.
Pinch or scroll to zoom · drag to pan — both axes move · double-click to reset
Classic floor-trader pivots from the last completed daily bar. Highlighted pills are the levels bracketing the current price.
Price Forecast
The range is measured volatility (ATR over the horizon), not a target — a wider band means a more volatile asset, not a stronger view. The direction is the indicator tally below. Every forecast is recorded when made and scored against the real price when it comes due, including the wrong ones. Not a recommendation, and not a fatwa.
Technical Summary
Standard indicator thresholds (RSI 30/70, Stochastic 20/80, CCI ±100, Williams %R −80/−20, MACD histogram sign, price vs. average) computed on daily bars. A summary of what common indicators say — not a recommendation, and not this site's own trading verdict.
Every indicator, and what it reads
| Indicator | Value | Signal |
|---|---|---|
| RSI (14) | 60.40 | NEUTRAL |
| Stochastic %K (14) | 56.83 | NEUTRAL |
| CCI (20) | 104.38 | SELL |
| Williams %R (14) | -43.17 | NEUTRAL |
| MACD (12,26,9) | 0.10 | BUY |
| ROC (10) | 1.80 | BUY |
| Momentum (10) | 0.65 | BUY |
| EMA (10) | 36.81 | BUY |
| SMA (10) | 36.71 | BUY |
| EMA (20) | 36.42 | BUY |
| SMA (20) | 36.38 | BUY |
| EMA (30) | 36.19 | BUY |
| SMA (30) | 35.79 | BUY |
| EMA (50) | 35.97 | BUY |
| SMA (50) | 35.72 | BUY |
| EMA (100) | 35.76 | BUY |
| SMA (100) | 35.53 | BUY |
| EMA (200) | 35.84 | BUY |
| SMA (200) | 35.62 | BUY |
About VanEck Morningstar International Moat ETF
The fund normally invests at least 80% of its total assets in securities that comprise the fund's benchmark index. The index is comprised of securities issued by companies that Morningstar, Inc. ("Morningstar") determines have sustainable competitive advantages based on a proprietary methodology that considers quantitative and qualitative factors ("wide moat companies"). The fund is non-diversified.
Background via Yahoo Finance — informational, not part of the verdict.
Weak — low conviction, small size or skip
SMC — Top Down
Market structure by timeframe, read from real bars. A bias per timeframe rather than a forecast — timeframes disagreeing is information, not noise.
| Timeframe | Bias | Bars |
|---|---|---|
| 📅 Daily | BULLISH | 42 |
| ⏱ 15-Min | BULLISH | 38 |
| ⏲ 5-Min | BEARISH | 116 |
Momentum & Volume
Rate of change and relative volume against this symbol's own recent history. Momentum describes what price has done; it is not a claim about what it will do.
Peer Movement
How the rest of the sector moved over the same window. Context for a price move, never a cause of one.
Peer movement computing — it will appear here on its own.
Before you act on this
The questions worth asking about any verdict on this page, answered plainly.
Is a fund screened on its name?
No. HTR reads the fund's filed holdings and screens each one, then reports the result by weight. A fund marketed as Islamic still gets the same look-through as any other.
What does unrated weight mean?
It is the share of the fund whose holdings HTR cannot cover far enough to rate. It is reported as unrated rather than counted as compliant, because a holding nobody screened should not look like one that passed.
Does the issuer's board make it compliant?
It matters, and it is noted, but it does not replace the look-through. The board's judgement and the holdings screen are shown separately so you can see when they agree and when they do not.
How often is this re-screened?
When the fund files new holdings, and on a rolling basis besides. The date on the verdict above is the last time this fund was actually recomputed.
Open research, not a fatwa. HTR applies published screening standards to filings and publishes what they say, including when they disagree. Nothing here is financial advice or a recommendation to buy or sell. Verdicts can change when new filings land.
Compare with
Same screen, different answers. Comparison is where the standards disagreeing becomes useful rather than confusing.
Peer screening computing — it will appear here on its own.
Insider Activity (90d)
Insider transactions reported in the last ninety days. Insiders sell for reasons that have nothing to do with a view, so a sale on its own is not a signal.
NO DATA 0 buys · 0 sells
COT Positioning — E-MINI S&P 500 - CHICAGO MERCANTILE EXCHANGE
The weekly CFTC Commitments of Traders report for the broad market it tracks, not for this symbol. Positioning context for the tape — it says nothing about this company.
NEUTRAL report date 2026-11-03 · Asset managers net 928584 (+5135)
AI Summary
Plain-language summary of the evidence already on this page — the Sharia screen, structure, momentum, and order flow above. It explains the read; it doesn't make the call. Generated on demand (a live AI call), never run automatically.